Mbal in Excel

[temr]

I made small program for material balance equation
Program still in debug and testing mode so any comments are welcome
Manual is on its way the program is simple and ease to use for people who familiar with Mbal
Link to program

[link Point to another website Only the registered members can access] link to info

[link Point to another website Only the registered members can access] Link to folder

[link Point to another website Only the registered members can access]

[aissine]

thanks

[temr]

Folks, thanks for thanx but i need your input and feedback

[darcyoil]

Hi temr.

Some of us old-fashioned folks are still swimming in MS Office 2003. Your file is in MS-O 2007 or more recent, and doesn't convert without corruption. Please can we request you to post in old .xls format so that we may review and provide feedback?

Many thanks.

[temr]

Hi temr.

Some of us old-fashioned folks are still swimming in MS Office 2003. Your file is in MS-O 2007 or more recent, and doesn't convert without corruption. Please can we request you to post in old .xls format so that we may review and provide feedback?

Many thanks.

Please find below

[link Point to another website Only the registered members can access]

[vinomarky]

It's a nice effort, but I think you may be reinventing the wheel a bit. Here's some sheets I use

[link Point to another website Only the registered members can access]

[temr]

It's a nice effort, but I think you may be reinventing the wheel a bit. Here's some sheets I use

[link Point to another website Only the registered members can access]

Thanks for the link but , i am not inventing the "wheel" i want to understand how the "wheel" is working - thats what i call engineering

[vinomarky]

Sorry - I misunderstood...... normally when someone takes the time to even make a manual for something I assume it is for more than a self-help excercise.

You are correct in that seeking to understand how the wheel works is indeed what engineering is about - I've been one for half my life... In that time, I have come to the strong opinion that being a responsible engineer also involves helping people when needed (an opinion which I know you share - nice Eclipse tutorial!), which was what I thought I was doing - sorry if I inadvertently stepped on toes

[temr]

Sorry - I misunderstood...... normally when someone takes the time to even make a manual for something I assume it is for more than a self-help excercise.

You are correct in that seeking to understand how the wheel works is indeed what engineering is about - I've been one for half my life... In that time, I come to the strong opinion that being a responsible engineer also involves helping people when needed (which I know you share - nice Eclipse tutorial!), which was what I thought I was doing - sorry if I inadvertently stepped on toes

It is ok i just put the point why i post here the mbal program
thanks again for the files

[darcyoil]

Hi temr.

Checked the .xls file (thanks, by the way), but the problem persists - and I get an error message saying "too many cells to format". This was the same error when I converted your MSO 2007 file to 2003. Bad luck for us old fashioned excel users I guess.

[temr]

Hello darcyoil,
then why no to shift to 2007?
is is more advance comparing to 2003 also the restriction of having only 256 columns in one sheet have been removed as far as i remember )))

[darcyoil]

Temr !! I give up. You're worse than my boss (who is ooooold, and is already surfing on Vista/7 OS's). I know, I know.....give me time to change. In the meanwhile, kudos on an excellent effort. Sometimes, re-inventing the wheel makes you a master craftsman.