ETAP vs Easy Power. What is better?

[qqitek]

Hello Fellows,

I am new on this forum, and honestly speaking -I am amazed about how helpfull it is!
It is simple excellent!

But coming to the topic - my company wants to choose dedictaed software for electrical calculation (load flows, short circuits, motor starting, generators, etc. for power plants and industry sector).
We (electrical team) need to test some programs.

Initially, I shortlisted as below:
a)for calculations:
-Easy power
-Etap

b)for grounding etc,
-CDEGS
-CYME

Pls advice me, what is better, what suits you more, what is more user friendly?
Any other ideas?
What do you use?

Best regards,
qqitek

[instsuresh]

May be u can go with etap..thats proven one in the industry

[srinivas.mh]

Hi there
do u have the working copy of etap,and other softwares related to electrical engineering.I wish to have it
hope you can share

regards
balku

[qqitek]

Hello,

i've downloaded official demo version from company web page.

If you want older version, try google. It can find everything.
Exemplary links:

[link Point to another website Only the registered members can access]

[link Point to another website Only the registered members can access]

[link Point to another website Only the registered members can access]
I believe that's enough, heh?

Best regards,
qqitek

[rahgoshafan]

hi
please share -----.

[Nathim]

Hello Fellows,

I am new on this forum, and honestly speaking -I am amazed about how helpfull it is!
It is simple excellent!

But coming to the topic - my company wants to choose dedictaed software for electrical calculation (load flows, short circuits, motor starting, generators, etc. for power plants and industry sector).
We (electrical team) need to test some programs.

Initially, I shortlisted as below:
a)for calculations:
-Easy power
-Etap

b)for grounding etc,
-CDEGS
-CYME

Pls advice me, what is better, what suits you more, what is more user friendly?
Any other ideas?
What do you use?

Best regards,
qqitek

We are using PSS of WestingHouse (Siemense)

and it is v good

[Setto72mr]

ETAP 7.0.0 System Requirements:

Operating System (32-bit or 64-bit)

* Microsoft® Windows Vista® (Home Premium, Business, Enterprise)
* Microsoft® Windows® XP (SP3) (Professional or Home Edition)
* Microsoft® Server 2008
* Microsoft® Server 2003 R2 (SP2)
* Microsoft® Server 2003 (SP2)

Software Requirements

* Microsoft® Internet Explorer® 5.01 or higher (or minimum version level as specified by the operating system in use)
* Microsoft® .NET Framework v1.1 (SP1)
* Microsoft® .NET Framework v2.0 (SP1)

Hardware Requirements

* USB port (for stand-alone license)
* Ethernet port with network access (for network license)
* DVD drive
* 5 to 80 GB hard disk space (based on project size, number of buses)
* 19” monitors recommended (dual monitors highly recommended)
* Minimum display resolution - 1024x768

Recommended Hardware

100 Bus Projects

* Intel® dual/quad core - 2.0 GHz (or equivalent)
* 2 GB RAM

500 Bus Projects

* Intel® dual/quad core - 2.0 GHz (or equivalent)
* 4 GB RAM

1,000 Bus Projects

* Intel® dual/quad core - 3.0 GHz with hyper-threading with high speed bus (or equivalent)
* 8 GB RAM (high speed)
* 64-bit operating system

10,000 Bus Projects and Higher

* Intel® dual/quad core - 3.0 GHz with hyper-threading with high speed bus (or equivalent)
* 12 GB RAM (high speed)
* 64-bit operating system

So,

1. Processer: Intel® dual/quad core - min 2.0 GHz (or equivalent)

2. For small networks (100 - 500 buses), ordinary computer: 2 - 4 GB RAM, Operating System - min Windows XP SP3, 32-bit

3. For bigger networks (1,000 buses and higher), powerful computer: min 8 GB RAM, Operating System - min Windows XP SP3, 64-bit.

[qqitek]

Hello,

finally my company decided to go with ETAP.
Maybe it is similar to Easy Power, but it gives possibility to export single lines directly to smart plant.

rgds
qq

[sms149]

ETAP is more user friendly compare to the other softwares

[newbie_Ee]

anyone has ETAP 7 which is working on windows 7 64bit?

[raj151857]

In my Opinion "Only ETAP" will not suggest any other software bcoz Only ETAP is having Excellent Libary & tools.

[sms149]

pls upload the ETAP link again